Best Pizza in Celebration FL (Top Local Picks)
There’s something magical about grabbing a hot slice of pizza in a town that already feels like a movie set.
I’ve been coming to Celebration for decades, and now that I call it home, pizza night hits a little different. My sons always loved to grab a slice and then walk to the dancing fountains! Whether it's a casual weekday dinner or a Friday night tradition, this town has some truly great spots to satisfy a pizza craving — and I’ve definitely done the legwork.
So if you’re in town and wondering where to get the best pizza in Celebration, FL… here are my go-to picks. From thin crust to build-your-own to crispy tavern pies, there’s a slice here with your name on it.
🏡 1. Upper Crust Pizza - Best Pizza in Celebration!
If Celebration had a hometown pizza joint, this would be it. Upper Crust Pizza sits right in the heart of downtown and has been serving locals and visitors for years. Their white pizza with garlic and ricotta is my personal favorite, but honestly, everything’s good. Grab a slice, sit outside, and soak in the Market Street charm — it doesn’t get more “Celebration” than this. Check out their menu.
🍕 2. Posto Pizza
Posto Pizza delivers that perfect balance of flavor and vibe. Their classic cheese and pepperoni are always a hit, but it’s the specialty pies that set them apart — bold ingredients, generous toppings, and a crust that hits just right. The owners care, and it shows. It’s a newer addition to Celebration, but already feels like it belongs. Check out their menu.
🇮🇹 3. Little Italy Celebration
This family-owned spot offers authentic Italian charm and some of the best traditional hand-tossed pies around. Their meat lovers pizza is loaded, and the margherita is fresh and flavorful. If you're looking for that old-school, hearty Italian experience — this is it. Bonus: great pasta and wine if you’re staying for a full meal.
📰 4. The Pizza Press
Custom pizzas made fresh, fast, and exactly how you like them. The Pizza Press is ideal if you’re dining with a group (or picky eaters), since you can build your own from start to finish. Their “Front Page” signature pie is a go-to, and they have a solid selection of local craft beer. It’s casual, fun, and perfect for families. Check out their menu.
Need more than slice, check out my guide to the best restaurants in Celebration.
👨👩👧👦 5. Celebration Town Tavern (Yes, really!)
You might not expect it, but the Tavern’s thin, bar-style pizza is seriously underrated hidden gem. I really mean hidden, off menu hidden, ask your server for current offerings. Crispy edges, bold toppings, and a lively atmosphere make it one of my favorite surprises in town. Whether you’re watching a game or just want something quick and satisfying — this slice hits the spot. Not on the menu, but check out here CTT here.
🙌 Honorable Mentions
Reggiano’s of Celebration – More of an upscale Italian destination, but their Neapolitan-style pizza is a hidden gem on the menu. Ideal for a classy date night.
Buca di Beppo – Over-the-top in the best way. Great for groups, birthdays, or big family-style meals where a massive deep-dish pizza makes perfect sense.
🗺️ Bonus: Planning a Celebration Food Tour?
I’m putting together a guide to my favorite eats all over town. If you’re looking beyond pizza, be sure to check out the our Restaurants in Celebration FL post. I’ll keep updating it as I eat my way through town — for research, of course. 😉
🍴 What’s Your Favorite?
Did I miss your go-to pizza place in Celebration?
Drop a comment and let me know what slice I need to try next — or tell me your favorite toppings (team pineapple welcome… mostly).
